Kyle made a single appearance for Lane United in 2018, but made it count with a first-half hat trick against TSS Rovers. Coffee was selected 41st overall in the 2019 MLS SuperDraft by Real Salt Lake and signed for the club’s USL Championship affiliate Real Monarchs, with whom he scored 9 goals in 27 appearances. Coffee retired after one season with the Monarchs and is now an assistant coach at Dixie State University.